Keep me updated!
Owning a home, condo, car or commercial building often comes with an unwelcome surprise: You’re required to buy insurance. In the Land of the Free, being told you “must” purchase something feels frustrating — even unfair. But when you zoom out and look at why these requirements exist,
the logic becomes clear. And yes, if you really want to opt out, there is a way.
Here’s how insurance requirements really work — and why they’re designed to protect
your investment just as much as the lender’s.
Insurance Is Required Because of Collateral
Collateral is simply this:
Something valuable you pledge to secure a loan.
When you borrow money, you’re asking a bank to take a risk on you. The lender gives you tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars based on a promise that you’ll pay it back. But promises don’t rebuild burned homes or replace stolen cars.
Let’s break it down.
Why Your Car Loan Requires Auto Insurance
Imagine you’re buying a $31,000 car and you’re putting down $5,000. The bank covers the other $26,000. Now imagine:
- The car is stolen
- It’s totaled in a crash
- A major repair wipes out its value
Are you going to keep paying $600+ per month for a car that no longer exists?
Of course not — and lenders know that.
Insurance protects the bank’s collateral.
If the car is destroyed or stolen, the insurer cuts the check, not you.
In other words:
Keep me updated!
Your insurance policy isn’t just your protection — it’s protection for the bank’s money.
Why Your Mortgage Requires Homeowners Insurance
A home is the largest investment most people will ever make — and unlike a car, it can literally disappear overnight.
Picture this:
You throw a great party. Everyone goes home. You leave to grab breakfast … but someone left something smoldering behind the couch. Within minutes, your home burns to the ground.
You still owe 28 years of mortgage payments.
Without homeowners insurance, the bank stands to lose hundreds of thousands — maybe millions — of dollars. With insurance, the collateral is protected, and your home can be rebuilt.
Again, the “requirement” is simply a lender saying:
“If we’re going to invest, we need a guarantee that the asset will still exist.”
The One Way to Avoid Insurance Requirements
Yes, there is a way to avoid being forced to buy insurance:
Buy the asset outright with cash.
- Want to avoid auto insurance requirements?
Buy the car with cash. (Most states still require proof of financial responsibility.) - Want to avoid homeowners insurance requirements?
- Buy the home with cash.
When you don’t borrow money from anyone, no one can require you to protect their investment — because it’s your investment now.
Reframing Insurance as a Benefit — Not a Burden
Instead of viewing insurance as a forced expense, think of it as:
- A financial safety net
- A way to protect your assets
- A tool that keeps you from starting over at zero
- A guarantee that disaster won’t wipe out years of savings or equity
You’re not just insuring the bank’s money —
you’re insuring your own financial stability.
Without it, one accident, one fire, one theft could turn your life upside down.
Maybe being “forced” to protect yourself isn’t such a bad deal after all.
Want to learn more about insurance? Visit KarlSusman.com.
Keep me updated!
